Essex, England, 1645. With a heavy heart, Alice Hopkins returns to the small town she grew up in. Widowed, with child, and without prospects, she is forced to find refuge at the house of her younger brother, Matthew. In the five years she has been gone, the boy she knew has become a man of influence and wealth–but more has changed than merely his fortunes. Alice fears that even as the cruel burns of a childhood accident still mark his face, something terrible has scarred Matthew’s soul. 

There is a new darkness in the town, too–frightened whispers are stirring in the streets, and Alice’s blood runs cold with dread when she discovers that Matthew is a ruthless hunter of suspected witches. Torn between devotion to her brother and horror at what he’s become, Alice is desperate to intervene–and deathly afraid of the consequences. But as Matthew’s reign of terror spreads, Alice must choose between her safety and her soul.
Alone and surrounded by suspicious eyes, Alice seeks out the fuel firing her brother’s brutal mission–and is drawn into the Hopkins family’s past. There she finds secrets nested within secrets: and at their heart, the poisonous truth. Only by putting her own life and liberty in peril can she defeat this darkest of evils–before more innocent women are forced to the gallows.

Growing up I have always been fascinated with Witchcraft and the persecution of women believed to be witches. It all stemmed from the fact that I am a red-head and was intrigued why women throughout the centuries were almost immediately found guilty of practicing witchcraft just because they had red hair (although women with other hair colors were persecuted too!)… which is supposedly a sign of the devil. If you think about it now it is so crazy that these men and even women used to think this! If somebody was called a witch today because of their red hair they would immediately be laughed at, it’s so ridiculous! My point is though that because I love history and love reading about witchcraft it meant that I was destined to love this novel and love it I do! This novel, this magnificent, brilliant, thrilling novel is incredible! I am so shocked by how much I loved this, I knew I would of course but not to this extent. Something about this book is special and I can’t stop thinking about it. I would already recommend you to read this novel because it is brilliant! Here is a little bit more about this wonderful book.

Long before the horror of the Salem Witch Trials which saw so much destruction and devastation, there were the Manningtree Witch Trials in Essex England, and for many women who lived there, it was a time of pure terror and torment. The Manningtree Witch Trials was a real-life event so the fact that this novel is based on these events makes the novel even more terrifying and chilling. The novel is predominately Historical Fiction but it is sprinkled with many true-life facts of the witch trial that happened in Essex but this next paragraph will be more about the fictional side of this novel!

The Witchfinder’s Sister starts out in London, England 1645 and follows our protagonist Alice Hopkins. Alice has discovered that she is pregnant however her husband has sadly passed away so she has no choice but to return to her home village of Manningtree, Essex. She will be living with her brother Matthew Hopkins (who was a real person during the witch trials) who is known as ‘The Witchfinder General’. Matthew is a cruel, troubled, violent and sullen individual who has an air of evil about him. He is a nasty piece of work and is not to be messed with. Alice soon discovers that Matthew is not only a man of influence these days rather a merciless and ruthless hunter of witches. His very name incites terror in the hearts of ordinary people for miles around. This is where our novel really begins as Alice tries her best to reign Matthew in; however, Matthew is ruthless and determined and will not be thwarted in his quest to bring these ‘so-called’ witches to trial. As Alice continues to try and understand his motives she uncovers some very dark and disturbing secrets which go back not only years but decades to when they were children, however, her discovering these secrets puts her own life in peril.

First off can we please appreciate how incredible the premise of this novel is! That is why I had to read this novel, it captured me straight away and all I could do was surrender to its wonder. The Witchfinder’s Sister is a harrowing, dark tale and is made even more so by the fact that a man named Matthew Hopkins did exist and that the witch trials that take place in this book also happened. Hopkins took the office of Witchfinder general upon himself and this was very much self-appointed and he was never truly recognized by Parliament. This in itself gives great insight into the character of Matthew as it shows just how determined he was to hunt down these witches and how he took the duty upon himself in his own free time. If anything it is sad that somebody could be that disturbed to do such a thing. However, we have to remember as readers that the times were different back then and Witchcraft was seen as a huge problem.

The Witchfinder’s Sister is a very harrowing story for two reasons. One because it is a thrilling, brutal story but secondly because this book highlights how awful it was for women to live during these ‘witch hunts’. These women were persecuted for the most insane things. Back then these poor women were tried if they were just a little different…a little eccentric and the majority of them were lonely women unable to fend for themselves due to mental health or their unfortunate circumstances. It is so tragically sad so I really do appreciate Underdown for highlighting what these women sadly went through.

Our protagonist Alice is absolutely incredible and I really adored her! She is a woman of her time and a woman who thinks for herself and states her beliefs. However back then this was frowned upon so I am sure you can tell that her living in 1645 meant that this got her in A LOT of trouble, especially with her sadistic brother Matthew. Speaking of Matthew! Wow, Underdown has really created an evil mastermind here. His character chills you to your core. He is the product of deficient nurture and weirdly for a moment I actually felt sorry for him! However, then I read about all the heinous things he had done to these poor women so no, I hate him! Such an evil piece of work but his character was so riveting to read! It is really exciting as a reader for your two main characters to be polar opposites. Alice, the sweet loving sister, and Matthew, the creepy messed up brother! It was such a delight and thrill to experience these two characters.

This book is very atmospheric and accurate of the time in which the book is set and for that I applaud Underdown. She instills the fear of witch hunting so masterfully into the reader that you can’t help but feels anxious and tense as you are reading it…yes, her writing is that good! At some points during the novel she made me feel as if I was being persecuted and although I was terrified reading it it was really wonderful to experience these feelings as it shows that I am reading a book by an incredible writer!

Underdown’s writing is incredibly paced and well thought out. Her prose is that of an enchantress, it was magical and captured me until the very final page. The tension she managed to create was wonderful, I could feel this tension growing more and more as the pages turned and it kept me hooked and wanting to read until I couldn’t no more.

I loved many aspects of this novel; I loved the brilliantly crafted story which has an intricately woven depth to it, I adored the characters and I loved the enchanting writing. What I also loved was how this book is set in England but 1640’s England! I am sure many of you by now know that I love history. England is my birth home so to read about it but from a vantage point of centuries ago was perfect as two of my loves were rolled into one! I could sense straight away when I was reading Underdowns descriptive writing that she has done a lot of research…right down to the details of the 16th century. Her writing of the clothing, furniture, possessions of the people who lived there made me feel that I was standing in the street or house watching the story pass by.

To summarise my points I would say that The Witchfinder’s Sister is a deeply moving but haunting account of a very violent period in history and if you adore history like me, which has expertly created fiction woven around it and bound to it then you will simply love this novel! To say I am happy to have read this book is an understatement, it was stunning and I really implore you lovely readers to read it! The Witchfinder’s Sister gets a magical Four Stars from me!

Thank you so much for reading as always fellow book lovers, I appreciate it so much and really appreciate the time you take out of your day to read my reviews, thank you so much! Please do comment below and let me know every thought of yours about this book which is whizzing around in your head. I would love to know whether you love historical fiction as a genre and whether you too are interested in witches and even if you believe in them and the power of magic, I would love to know! Thank you so much again!

Goodbye for now book lovers,

P.S. Here is a preview of the book for all of you lovely readers to enjoy! Please have a read of the preview and if you find that you have loved what you have read then all you need to do is click the Buy on Amazon button and it will take you straight to the book on Amazon USA! If you are in the U.K. then below I have attached a link to the book for the Amazon U.K. website. I have also attached some links about the author and this wonderful book! Thank you so much again for reading book lovers, I can’t wait to hear your thoughts on this book!   

Amazon U.K. / Goodreads / Book Depository / Publisher; Penguin – Viking

P.P.S. How beautiful is this cover?! I am in book heaven right now!

You May Also Like

191 comments

Reply

thanks so much for this – really useful for my A level History!

Reply

Hi there! Thank you so much for comment what should I call you? (:

well my site name is theartanorak – bit of an art buff – actually A level student called Martha – I believe you follow my site – In The Frame?

I love art so much and yes I think I do (:

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate the comment so thank you so much again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world?

I look forward to your reply!

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate the comment so thank you so much again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world?

I look forward to your reply!

Reply

I am glad I could put a little bit of history in my review for you but in a fun way I hope!

Reply

I wish I had studied history at A level but back then I was just too obsessed about Psychology!

Reply

Do you think you could read this book?

definitely!

Aww great!

Let me know if ever you see yourself reading it (:

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate the comment so thank you so much again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world?

I look forward to your reply!

Reply

I keep hearing good things about this book. It’s not usually the type of thing I go for, but I may have to add it to my TBR. Also, I have been known to pick up books solely for a good cover! 🙂

Reply

Hi Samantha! Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting (:

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate the comment so thank you so much again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world?

I look forward to your reply!

Reply

I think this book is so great that it is worth the read despite it not being your most loved genre!

Reply

It’s definitely scary I think to read a book out of your comfort zone but I take the risk sometimes and it is always great! I would really recommend you reading this (:

Maybe closer to Halloween – to give it the right feel 😉

Reply

Thank god it is not just me! Haha. I do this ALL the time too Samantha. This book really is a beautiful cover and it would look great on any book shelf (:

Yeah, I first passed up Outlander for about 3 years (back in the 90’s) when the only copy at my Gran’s house was HIDEOUS. When there was literally nothing else I hadn’t read yet, I picked it up anyway – and it became my all time favorite book! 😀

Aww I definitely need to read outlander now that you said this! Did you watch the tv series ? (:

Reply

Can I ask what you are reading right now? (:

I’ve been book hopping, at the moment I’m actively going between Dorothy Parker’s “Complete Stories”, “On the Road” by Jack Kerouac (re-read), and “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” by Stowe .

Hi there! I am so sorry for only just replying weirdly your comment went to my spam so I am so sorry I missed this!

How did your re read of on the road go? That is one of my favourite novels and I love it so much! Did you get a chance to watch the recent movie?

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

Ha! Fascinating. I probably wouldn’t buy this book but it still sounds like a great read.

Reply

It really is Nthato! Do you read much of these kind of novels? (:

Not at all actually.

You should definitely try and read this one then it is great (:

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Thanks for dropping by. Looking forward to seeing what content you come up with! 🙂

Reply

Love the cover and I have a feeling I’ll be reading this one soon <3 Looks awesome, I've always liked the witches theme too!

Reply

Thank you so much for commenting Annie I appreciate it so much! (:

Reply

The cover is just so beautiful right? The hardback edition is lovely and the actual cover is green and so lovely!

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

Because I am guilty, I definitely will end up loving a book more if the cover is gorgeous lol. Is this the same with you too? (:

Haha Totally, I love me a beautiful cover!

Thank god I am not the only one! lol.

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

I have this book, and I’m looking forward to reading it – I also live in Essex not far from Manningtree and have seen the Witch Hunter Generals house, which is why I bought it!

Reply

Thank you so much for commenting Melanie I really appreciate it (:

Reply

This is so amazing that you live in Essex and that you actually bought this book because it’s events are close to your home town!

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

I am from originally from the south east of England too but I live in America now so reading about my home country was amazing! Doesn’t the premise of this story just sound amazing?!

Yes it really does, I love reading historical novels anyway but the witch hunts fascinate me!

So do I! Historical fiction as well as historical books are such a love of mine so the fact that this book focuses on a topic I am obsessed with meant I adored it!

I cant wait for you to read it! Come back and let me know what you think about it (:

Also can I ask what you are reading right now? (:

I am currently reading A Vintage Wedding by Katie Fforde – what are you currently reading

I haven’t heard of this, it sounds good though! Is it a romantic novel?

I’m only a couple of chapters in so haven’t found the love interest yet…i’m assuming there will be though!

There should be eventually with a title like that! Lol.

I’m reading into the water by Paula Hawkins and it is so great! (:

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

This looks fascinating, adding to my TBR

Reply

Thank you so much for commenting, I appreciate it so much!

Reply

What is your name by the way? (:

Rich

Aww lovely, nice to meet you!

Great to meet you too! 😀

I always love meeting fellow book lovers!

So what are you reading right now? (:

Right now I’ve got an ARC on Meditation, an ARC of Select by Marit Weisenberg and another Hourly History on the go.

These sounds great! I will have to have a look for these now. Thanks!

Select has a decent premise but it’s not grabbing me yet, not far in yet though.

Keep me updated on if it gets better! (:

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

Oh gosh and it really is fascinating! Do you think you could see yourself reading it?

Definitely! I’ve requested on NetGalley but they’re after US readers now. Fingers crossed otherwise I’ll try my library but they’re usually terrible.

Aww great! Let me know when you read it!

Also do you have a fascination with witches? I do!

Not a fascination but a more than passing interest in Paganism etc.

Aww amazing! I have always been interested in Paganism too (:

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

I gave this one a solid 5 out of 5, it hooked me from page 1. Such an incredible debut, with really realistic characters and scenarios. Plus, such gorgeous prose!

Reply

Thank you for commenting Zuky! Is this what I should call you?

Reply

I am so happy somebody else has read this book, it means we can talk about how beautiful it is!

Reply

It is just the most incredible story isn’t it? So perfect and chilling!

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

Do you have a fascination with witches too? (:

Yeah, Zuky is my name! It was such a gorgeous book and yes I love reading about real life witch trials n stuff 😀

That is such a wonderful name! I love it!

Thank you x

Youre so welcome (: x

Oh I love reading about all of this stuff too. It is just so interesting. Plus I love history!

Reply

New to wordpress and had to say that your blog is awesome and so is this comment! Agree with what you said 100%. follow my blog for when its ready. Keep BOOK ROCKING!

Thank you so much for stopping by and commenting!

I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment so thanks again!

What is your name and where are you from in the world I am curious!

I look forward to your reply, thanks again!

Reply

What a beautiful cover! Thank you so much for your detailed and thorough review – I really enjoyed it:).

Reply

Thank you so much for commenting! What is your name if I may ask? (:

I’m Sarah – and you are Aimee, aren’t you?

Nice to meet you Sarah and yes my name is Aimee!

Yes – so sorry – I sort of forget that I go by my initials as my author name! And it’s a REALLY common name – there are so many Sarahs littering up the place there are even T-shirts for us… And I married a John – so we are the ultimate generic couple:)

There is nothing wrong with a generic name at all! Aimee is pretty common too but the spelling Amy more so !

I don’t lose much sleep over it – it got a bit of a problem when I was at teacher-training as there were SEVEN Sarahs in the same year group! I got nicknamed Abba Sarah:))

Haha! I can imagine. Thinking back on it I had around 4 teachers call Sarah! With me I used to get frustrated when the teachers spelt my name Amy and not Aimee. Or if they pronounced it wrong and would put a French twist on it. I dont mind but its just not how it is pronounced lol.

Well, you wouldn’t believe the mess folks make of my surname – Higbee… I think it is more common in the US than it is over here, but I’m regularly called Highbee or spelt with a ‘y’, which is more understandable.

It’s a little frustrating isn’t it when people can’t spell it right no?! My surname before marriage was pretty tricky but my married name now is easy as anything thank god!

Yes – I wouldn’t mind, but my name isn’t even tricky!

Haha exactly! It’s hardly like its Arnold Schwarzenegger! Lol.

Absolutely! It makes you wonder how he copes!

Haha I know! I think I would go mad if I had a surname like him!

My parents are french obsessed hence the french spelling (: I love it though.

It’s a really pretty version of the name, I think:).

Aww thank you, I love the name Sarah. Its origins are of a goddess no? I am pretty sure (:

lol – you’ve promoted me! It’s Princess, apparently…

Oh yes! That is what I was thinking of. My mum is called Sarah and I remember she had this magnet about the name Sarah. So lovely though! Mine just means Love and of course is a French name (:

Oh – of course it does – t’aime! How lovely:))

My parents love of the French though has been passed down to me, I just adore it! The people, the culture, the food, the scenery! Everything.

It’s beautiful country – my sister lives in France and loves it, though she will be moving back to the UK during the year.

Aww how lovely! I love France and adore everytime me and my husband visit. There is just so much to do and see there but not enough time!

It’s a big country and so beautiful…

So beautiful! Have you visited much?

I want to experience the real France you know? Not just the tourist side. That is the same with every country though!

Which is always a great treat when it happens:)

Reply

Thank you for your kind words that is so sweet of you. Do you think you could see yourself reading this book?

I certainly would – though at present I’m fairly well stacked out with Netgalley arcs and a teetering TBR pile… It’s all getting a bit ridiculous!

Haha, I know that feeling!

It is so hard being a reader sometimes, there is just not enough time in the world to read!

Oh for sure! I sometimes wish I had a time-turner – and one of the things I would do would be to set one of the timelines to READ mode.

Yes! Wouldn’t that just be the most perfect thing in the whole entire world?!

Oh, it would, wouldn’t it?

It really would Sarah!

Have you ever seen the movie About Time? Its directed by Richard Curtis, the person who done all those great British movies such as Love Actually and Notting Hill.

Anyway the premise of the movie is that the men in this family can time travel and the father Bill Nighy is OBSESSED with books. So instead of going back in time for ‘important’ things he travels back in time so he can read more and more and read his favourite books over and over again.

It is the loveliest movie ever and you would really adore it, especially because of the book part (:

Sorry for rambling but that just really reminded me of what you said!

Oh, that sounds fab! I’ll keep an eye out for it – see if we can get hold of it. Richard Curtis films are always worth watching – thank you for the recommendation:)

Youre welcome! I think you would really love it, it is so heart warming. Plus I love the director and all the actors! (:

I’ll let you know how I get on if we manage to track it down!

Great ! (:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *